unmanlyfesto for teaching in the future, part 1

The next time I teach freshman writing, I will:

• Use the Learning Record;
• Add a description of “independence” to the description of the dimension of learning called “confidence and independence”;
• Grade individual assignments on A-F scale but clearly indicate to the students that I will NOT tally these grades to determine their final grades. Instead, the student will still present an argument for their grade based on the framework provided by the Learning Record, and they will receive a grade from me based on their LR. This way, I can be as honest, clear, and direct as possible about the quality of students’ work (because I will tell them in the familiar language of letter grades) but can still insist that very high quality doesn’t guarantee an A and below-average, barely acceptable work doesn’t guarantee a D.
• I will have questions to respond to for each assignment students complete, like the questions I used to respond to the LR.
• When students write multiple drafts of an essay, one of the questions I will respond to will have to do with the way the students responded to my comments on their earlier draft(s). I might even give a separate grade to indicate the quality of revision. The goal here is to evaluate the (evidence of) effort and thought that went into revision separately from the quality of the essay.